
Phonics Reform England: Not reading reform. Phonics reform. Improving phonics for the one in five at risk of struggling to read and spell.

A Comparison of the 45 DfE Validated Systematic, Synthetic Phonics Programmes
Parents, teachers, and school leaders often ask, “Which is the best phonics program?” However, that isn’t easy to answer.
To make an informed decision, they need to understand the bigger picture: what different phonics programmes include, how they are structured, and how they differ in practice. At present, this information is not available in one place. Although programmes are listed on this site, visitors will also be able to access the directory via SystematicSyntheticPhonics.com.
This comparison brings together the content of all 45 UK Department for Education-validated SSP programmes, so decisions can be based on what is actually taught, and so that gaps can be identified and support put in place where needed.
We will be inviting programme developers to create their own overview ‘strengths’ card, outlining what makes them different, and offering non-validated SSP programmes, including those from overseas, the opportunity to add their details.
Systematic, Synthetic Phonics Programmes
Synthetic phonics is an approach to early reading instruction based on teaching children how the written code of English represents spoken language.
At its core, it involves:
1. Teaching the alphabetic code
Children are taught that:
-
words are made up of phonemes (speech sounds)
-
these sounds are represented in print by graphemes (letters or letter groups)
2. Blending to read
Children learn to:
-
look at a written word
-
identify the graphemes
-
say the corresponding phonemes
-
blend those sounds together to read the word
For example:
c–a–t → cat
3. Segmenting to spell
Children are also taught the reverse process:
-
say a word
-
break it into phonemes
-
choose graphemes to represent those sounds
4. Systematic and explicit teaching
Instruction typically:
-
follows a planned sequence of grapheme–phoneme correspondences (GPCs)
-
introduces correspondences step by step
-
uses practice with decodable words that match what has been taught
5. Focus on decoding first
The approach emphasises:
-
learning to decode unfamiliar words using the code
-
rather than memorising whole words or relying on context
Key idea
Synthetic phonics is designed to give children a starting system for connecting speech and print, so they can begin to read words they haven’t seen before. It is a starting point as synthetic phonics programmes teach only a subset of the full code. Children are expected to extend beyond what’s been taught as they read more, which is where wider learning about the writing system develops.
When SSP validation was introduced
-
Formal SSP validation began after the Rose Review
-
This led to the phonics-first policy in England (from 2007 onwards)
-
The Phonics Screening Check (PSC) was introduced in 2012
-
A formal DfE validation list of SSP programmes followed, linked to funding
Major update to validation
-
In 2021, the Department for Education revalidated programmes under stricter criteria
-
Schools were required to:
-
use a validated SSP programme
-
or justify an alternative
-
This was part of the government’s push for “fidelity to programme”
What programmes had to align with (2021 framework)
Programmes were assessed against detailed DfE guidance, including:
1. Fidelity to a single programme
-
Schools should follow one SSP programme consistently
-
Not mix approaches
2. Clearly defined progression
-
A structured sequence of GPCs
-
Rapid teaching in Reception and Year 1
3. Daily phonics teaching
-
Whole-class, systematic instruction
-
Fast-paced and consistent
4. Teaching of blending and segmenting
-
Explicit modelling of:
-
blending for reading
-
segmenting for spelling
-
5. Use of decodable texts
-
Books must be:
-
fully decodable
-
matched to taught GPCs
-
6. Avoidance of “multi-cueing”
-
Programmes must NOT encourage:
-
guessing from pictures
-
context-based reading strategies
-
7. Coverage of a core GPC set
-
Typically around 90–100 correspondences
-
Introduced in a planned sequence
8. Assessment and intervention
-
Built-in assessment points
-
Support for children not keeping up
What evidence providers submitted
Programme developers had to provide:
-
full teaching materials
-
scope and sequence
-
training and implementation guidance
-
examples of decodable texts
These were reviewed by the DfE and an expert panel.
Validation confirmed that programmes:
-
follow SSP principles
-
meet DfE policy requirements
But it does NOT ensure:
-
full coverage of the alphabetic code
-
teacher understanding beyond programme content
-
that all children reach independent reading
The validation process ensures:
👉 consistency and compliance
But it does NOT guarantee:
👉 that children reach the self-teaching phase
Letters and Sounds was introduced by the Department for Education in 2007 as guidance for teaching early reading through phonics.
It is a systematic synthetic phonics approach designed to teach children how the alphabetic code works for both reading and spelling.
The programme is organised into six phases, typically spanning Nursery to Year 2:
-
Phase 1 focuses on listening, speaking, and phonological awareness
-
Phases 2–4 introduce and practise core grapheme–phoneme correspondences and blending/segmenting
-
Phases 5–6 develop knowledge of alternative spellings, pronunciations, and spelling patterns
It was widely adopted across England as a non-commercial framework, forming the basis for many later synthetic phonics programmes.
However, it was not a fully resourced programme and relied heavily on teacher interpretation, which led to variation in implementation.
The updated advice to the DfE regarding the old Letters and Sounds programme, and the recommended progression moving forward, can be seen at:
https://www.speechsoundplay.com/dfe-letters-and-sounds-ssp
The DfE recommended removing Phase 1 altogether for children in Reception. We strongly recommend a pre-phonics phase.
These are the Systemtic, Synthetic Phonics Programmes PRE are evaluating:
A Flying Start with Letters and Sounds
Email FlyingStartLS@westberks.gov.uk.
You can also visit A Flying Start with Letters and Sounds.
ACET Phonics
Email ACETphonics@astoncetrust.org.
You can also visit ACET.
All Aboard Phonics
Email schools@allaboardlearning.com or call 01865 632965.
You can also visit All Aboard Phonics.
ALS Phonics: Letters and Sounds
Email ann@alsphonics.co.uk or use the contact us form.
You can also visit ALS Phonics.
Anima Phonics: Letters and Sounds Updated
Email info@animaphonics.com or use the contact us form.
You can also visit Anima Phonics.
Bug Club Phonics
Email ukschools.customersuccess@pearson.com or request a call back.
You can also visit Bug Club Phonics.
Dramatic Progress in Literacy Phonics (DPiL Phonics)
Contact Nina Birch by visiting DPiL Phonics.
Essential Letters and Sounds
Email primary.salesconsultant@oup.com or contact your Oxford University Press (OUP) primary educational consultant.
You can also visit Essential Letters and Sounds.
Extend Letters and Sounds
Call 01934 313390.
You can also visit Extend Letters and Sounds.
FFT Success for All Phonics
Email phonics@fft.org.uk or call 01446 776262.
You can also visit FFT Success for All Phonics.
First Class Phonics
Email Jane Creed at jane@bced.co.uk or Debs Bragard at debs@bced.co.uk.
You can also visit First Class Phonics.
Fishing for Phonics
Email enquiries@fishingforphonics.co.uk.
You can also visit Fishing for Phonics.
Floppy’s Phonics
Email primary.salesconsultant@oup.com or contact your OUP primary educational consultant.
You can also visit Floppy’s Phonics for information about its teaching programme.
GES Simply Letters and Sounds
Email enquiry@ges-simplylettersandsounds.co.uk or info@global-educationservices.co.uk.
You can also visit GES Simply Letters and Sounds .
Jolly Phonics
Email Olly Rzysko, Head of Marketing, at olly@jollylearning.co.uk.
You can also visit Jolly Phonics.
Junior Learning Letters and Sounds
Email sales@juniorlearning.co.uk.
You can also visit Junior Learning Letters and Sounds.
LearnPhonics!
Email admin@learnphonics.co.uk.
You can also visit LearnPhonics!.
Lesley Clarke’s Letters and Sounds
Email mail@lesleyclarkesyntheticphonics.co.uk.
You can also visit Lesley Clarke’s Letters and Sounds.
Letterland
Email info@letterland.com or call 01223 262675.
You can also visit Letterland.
Little Wandle Letters and Sounds Revised
Email enquiries@littlewandlelettersandsounds.org.uk.
You can also visit Little Wandle Letters and Sounds Revised.
McKie Mastery Power Phonics
Email info@mckiemastery.co.uk.
You can also visit McKie Mastery Power Phonics.
Monster Phonics
Email info@monsterphonics.com or call 0800 211 8052.
You can also visit Monster Phonics.
No Nonsense Phonics
Email support@phonicsinternational.com or call 01635 800033.
You can also visit No Nonsense Phonics.
Pearl Phonics
Email info@theliteracyadvisor.co.uk.
You can also visit Pearl Phonics.
Phonics International
Email David Hepplewhite at support@phonicsinternational.com or Debbie Hepplewhite at debbie@phonicsinternational.com.
You can also visit Phonics International.
Phonics Shed
Email support@edshed.com.
You can also visit Phonics Shed.
Phonics Steps
Email phonics@sfet.org.uk.
You can also visit Phonics Steps.
Pip and Pap
Email pipandpap@manselpark.net.
You can also visit Pip and Pap.
Read Write Inc.
For programme information, training and support, visit Read Write Inc..
For resources information, visit Oxford University Press, email primary.enquiries@oup.com or call 01536 452610.
Reading Planet Rocket Phonics
Email Helen Parker, Senior Publisher, Rising Stars (Hodder Education Ltd) at helen.parker@risingstars-uk.com.
You can also visit Reading Planet Rocket Phonics.
Ready Steady Phonics
Email mari@literacycounts.co.uk or call 07522 514759.
You can also visit Ready Steady Phonics.
RoboPhonics
Visit RoboPhonics.
Schofield & Sims My Letters & Sounds
Email David Nesbitt, Head of School Sales, at david@schofieldandsims.co.uk.
You can also visit Schofield & Sims My Letters & Sounds.
Smart Kids: Letters and Sounds - The Code
Email sales@smartkids.co.uk or call 01488 644644.
You can also visit Smart Kids.
Snappy Sounds
Email International.curriculum@macmillaneducation.com.
You can also visit Snappy Sounds.
Song of Sounds
Email hello@songofsounds.co.uk.
You can also visit Song of Sounds.
Sound Discovery
Email emily.guille-marrett@pickatale.com.
You can also visit Sound Discovery.
Sound!Start Phonics for Letters and Sounds
Email alex.finn@soundstartphonics.co.uk or sales@soundstartphonics.co.uk.
You can also visit Sound!Start Phonics.
Sounds-Write
For programme information, training and support, visit Sounds-Write or use the enquiry form.
Supersonic Phonic Friends
Email supersonicphonicfriends@gmail.com.
Use the contact us form or call Anna Lucas on 07930 525230.
You can also visit Supersonic Phonic Friends.
The Partnership Phonics Programme (based on Letters and Sounds)
Email info@the-partnership.org.uk.
You can also visit The Partnership Phonics Programme.
Time for Phonics
Email hello@timeforphonics.co.uk.
You can also visit Time for Phonics.
Twinkl Phonics
Email schools@twinkl.co.uk or call 0114 352 0315.
You can also visit Twinkl Phonics.
Unlocking Letters and Sounds
Email Janine Ashman at ULS@sppschool.uk.
You can also visit Unlocking Letters and Sounds.
What Each SSP Programme Actually Teaches: A Clear Comparison to Support Informed Decisions
Comparing the 45 DfE-Validated Synthetic Phonics Programmes
In England, the UK Department for Education has published a list of systematic synthetic phonics (SSP) programmes that meet its validation criteria.
You can view the official list and guidance here:
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/choosing-a-phonics-teaching-programme
There are currently 45 programmes on this list.
Schools are not legally required to use a validated programme. However, government funding for phonics programmes has been made available only for programmes on this validated list. This includes funding for:
-
the purchase of a phonics programme
-
associated training and materials
This funding has been delivered through the English Hubs programme.
English Hubs work directly with partner schools and provide:
-
funding to purchase a validated SSP programme
-
funded training linked to that programme
-
in-school support from literacy specialists
Schools receiving this support are expected to:
-
select a single systematic synthetic phonics programme
-
implement it with fidelity across the school
As a result, although schools can technically choose any approach, access to funding and support is tied to programmes that meet the UK Department for Education validation criteria. In practice, this has led to widespread adoption of programmes from this list.
Despite this, there is no official comparison that shows, in detail, what each programme teaches, how it is structured, or how children are likely to experience it.
This page will provide that comparison.
What Phonics Reform England (PRE) Will Do
This page will systematically review all 45 validated SSP programmes using the same criteria, so that differences in content, structure, and approach can be seen clearly.
It will combine:
-
explicit mapping of what is taught
-
analysis of how it is taught
-
evaluation of likely learner experience
What Will Be Shown for Each Programme
Each programme will be analysed and presented using a small number of core features. These have been selected to provide a clear and consistent basis for comparison.
Grapheme–Phoneme Correspondences (Scope and Sequence)
-
The full set of grapheme–phoneme correspondences explicitly taught
-
The order in which they are introduced
-
How the sequence aligns with the UK Department for Education suggested progression for those aligned with the old Letters and Sounds Programme
This will make the scope and sequence visible for direct comparison.
High-Frequency and Common Exception Words
(downloadable resources eg Letters and Sounds HFWs Lists can be seen here)
-
The specific words included in the programme
-
The order in which they are introduced
-
How they are taught in practice
This includes whether words are:
-
mapped to sounds and spellings
-
partially analysed
-
or presented for recognition and recall
Reading Books and Text Alignment
-
The books used within each programme
-
How these texts align with the taught GPCs
-
What children are expected to read at each stage
This shows the relationship between teaching and reading practice.
Assessment and Progress Tracking
-
The assessments used within the programme
-
How progress is monitored
-
How decisions are made about moving children forward
This includes:
-
in-programme assessment
-
formal checks where used
-
tracking systems provided
Pre-Phonics and Early Risk Identification
-
Whether the programme includes assessment before phonics begins
-
How children at risk are identified early
-
What indicators are used to flag concern
Analytical Overview
Each programme will also include a short, evidence-informed overview of:
Strengths
-
In relation to the research base (science of reading)
-
In relation to how children learn (science of learning)
Limitations
-
Where gaps or constraints may arise
-
Where decisions are left to the teacher
Likely Learner Experience
A specific focus will be given to:
-
how a child is likely to experience the programme day to day
-
what happens when learning is secure
-
what happens when it is not
This includes particular attention to children at risk of not progressing as expected, often described as around 1 in 5 learners.
Why This Comparison Is Needed
All programmes on the UK Department for Education validated list were deemed to meet the same core criteria.
However, the detail of what is taught, how it is sequenced, and how children are supported is not currently presented in a way that allows direct comparison.
This page will make that information visible.
What You’ll Be Able to Do
Once complete, this comparison will allow you to:
-
compare programmes side by side
-
see exactly what is taught and when
-
understand how words and texts are introduced
-
review how progress is assessed
-
and consider how each programme may work for different learners
Phonics Program HFW Lists are analysed in depth on
https://www.thespellingroutine.com/phonics-programs
Sight words used in The Village With Three Corners are also shown. This is the levelled reader scheme we have mapped, to make the books fully decodable.

Share Your Child’s Experience with Phonics
If your child is not progressing as expected in phonics, we would like to hear about their experience of the specific programme being used in their school. Your feedback will help us understand how different programmes are working in practice for children who are at risk. Support@TheReadingHut.com
%20(1)%20-%20Copy.jpg)
